26 Christmas Candy Recipes You Can Actually Make

Cookies 'N Cream Fudge

Austin Kearns

Stuff your stockings with homemade versions this year. From fudge to toffee to caramels, homemade candy is a sweet way to show your loved ones you care this holiday season — especially since it appeals to their sweet tooth. For more Christmastime sweets, check out our easy Christmas cookie recipes and Christmas desserts.

Holiday Crack Candy Vertical

Chelsea Lupkin
Holiday Crack Candy

The addiction is so real.

Get the recipe from Delish.

BUY NOW Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware, $30, amazon.com

image

Chelsea Lupkin
Chocolate Toffee

Need a gift for friends, coworkers, and the babysitter? Chocolate toffee to the rescue.

Get the recipe from Delish.

image

Austin Kearns
Milk ‘n Cookies Fudge

tk

Get the recipe from Delish.

BUY NOW 8″x8″ Baking Pan, $14, amazon.com

image

Jon Boulton
Peppermint Oreo Truffles

How could something so simple be so good?

Get the recipe from Delish.

BUY NOW OXO Cookie Scoop, $14, amazon.com

Salted Caramels

Gift Salted Caramels and be forever loved.

Get the recipe from Delish.

BUY NOW Candy Thermometer, $12, amazon.com

image

Jon Boulton
Buttered Rum Fudge

Oh fudge.

Get the recipe from Delish.

BUY NOW 8″x8″ Baking Pans, $14, amazon.com

Twix Bars

Chelsea Lupkin
Twix Bars

Turn the candy aisle favorite into a homemade treat.

Get the recipe from Delish.

Almond Joy Bark

John Komar
Almond Joy Bark

Almond Joy brings the holiday spirit.

Get the recipe from Delish.

image

Brandon Bales
Toffee Bites

Individual Toffee Bites are perfect for sharing.

Get the recipe from Delish.

BUY NOW Silicone Ice Cube Trays, $10, amazon.com

Moscato Truffles

Perfect for girls night.

Get the recipe from Delish.

BUY NOW Moscato, $14, drizly.com

image

Charlie Gillette
Reese’s Fudge

Further proof PB and chocolate is the best combo.

Get the recipe from Delish.

No-Bake Oreo Truffles, 3 Ways: Original, Mint and Peanut Butter

Candace Braun Davison
No Bake Oreo Mint Truffles

Oreos, chocolate, mint—it’s the kind of thing our candy dreams are made of.

Get the recipe from Delish.

image

Ethan Calabrese
Gingerbread Fudge

With only five ingredients—sweetened condensed milk, white chocolate, and spices—this holiday treat is insanely easy to make.

Get the recipe from Delish.

Get the recipe from Teacher Chef.

Sally’s Baking Addiction
Peppermint Bark

Literally, the definition of Christmas candy.

Get the recipe from Sally’s Baking Addiction.

Samoa Truffles

The way more decadent way to eat your fave Girl Scout cookie.

Get the recipe from Delish.

Hot Chocolate Fudge

Ethan Calabrese
Hot Chocolate Fudge

Tiny marshmallows give this fudge recipe an added sweetness and subtle crunch.

Get the recipe from Delish.

BUY NOW Set of Pyrex Bowls, $12.50, amazon.com

image

Courtesy of Fake Ginger
Peanut Brittle

This homemade peanut brittle is amaze on top of other desserts, like ice cream or cupcakes.

Get the recipe from Fake Ginger.

image

Courtesy of Averie Cooks
Turtles

Chewy, gooey goodness.

Get the recipe from Averie Cooks.

image

Courtesy of Crazy for Crust
Butterscotch Squares

We’re down for anything dipped in chocolate.

Get the recipe from Crazy For Crust.

Caramel Rolo Fudge

A fudge recipe every caramel lover needs.

Get the recipe from Delish.

BUY NOW Set of Pyrex Bowls, $12.50, amazon.com

image

Courtesy of Garnish with Lemon
Fleur de Sel Caramels

Because caramel just isn’t as good without salt.

Get the recipe from Garnish with Lemon.

image

Courtesy of Lemon Tree Dwelling
White Chocolate Ting-a-Lings

You won’t be able to stop eating these sweet, crunchy treats.

Get the recipe from Lemon Tree Dwelling.

image

Courtesy of Chocolate With Grace
Buckeyes

We’ll take peanut butter + chocolate in literally any form.

Get the recipe from Chocolate With Grace.

image

Courtesy of Garnish & Glaze
Polar Bear Baws

Anything See’s Candies can do, so can you.

Get the recipe from Garnish & Glaze.

Disco Truffles

Party on the outside, cookie dough on the inside.

Get the recipe from Delish.

image

Courtesy of Creme de la Crumb
3-Ingredient Old Fashioned Potato Candy

The perfect homemade gift for peanut butter lovers!

Get the recipe from Creme de la Crumb.